By Dark Crime Diaries | 2025
In India, dignity is not always taken away in one visible, brutal act.
More often, it is stripped quietly across tables where no one looks up, corridors where files move faster than humans, and signatures that carry more weight than an actual human being standing in front of them.
There are people in our country who wake up every morning. They breathe, walk, speak, work, and worry about their next meal. Their heartbeat. Their families depend on them. Yet, they do not appear in official records. Not because they vanished, committed fraud, or broke the law, but because the system erased them without notice or explanation.
No police notice explains the erasure.
No court summons calls for a defence.
No formal letter recognises the error.
The revelation occurs accidentally at a ration shop, a bank counter, a hospital desk, or a pension office; when a screen displays a single, devastating line: ‘Status: deceased.’
One day, without ceremony or accountability, the system declares you dead.
When the system decides you no longer exist
For most victims, the discovery comes accidentally.
The pension does not arrive.
A ration dealer refuses food.
A bank account stops responding.
A hospital denies subsidised treatment.
At first, it appears to be a technical problem. Then, confusion sets in. After several visits, the truth emerges in a tone that appears regular to the official but devastating to the listener:
“Aap record ke hisaab se mar chuke ho.”
There are no apologies.
No urgency.
There’s no shock.
Just a screen that is more important than the person standing in front of it.
The first loss is not money; it’s dignity.
The first visit to a government office brings hope. The second creates anxiety. The third introduces humiliation.
People are asked to explain how they can be living if their records indicate otherwise. They are told to bring witnesses, certificates, photographs, and affidavits confirming that they are human beings.
Elderly people struggle to stand in lines meant for the young.
Disabled people are asked to return “with proper documents.”
Daily wage labourers lose money every day they chase correction.
Each visit becomes a test of endurance, rather than a test of eligibility.
What hurts more than financial loss is the tone: casual, mocking, and sometimes amused. As if the problem itself were absurd.
The system does not bend. The person does.
A system that makes you bow repeatedly
There is no single authority responsible for restoring a life that has been wrongly erased. One office refers you to another. One department requested a paper issued by another department, which refuses responsibility.
Files travel slowly. Clerks hesitate. Officers avoid ownership.
People bowed repeatedly.
They bow to officials half their age.
They wait outside offices that may not be open that day.
They return home with “come tomorrow” stamped into their exhaustion.
The error is due to a system issue.
The burden is entirely on the citizen.
When Survival Requires Proof, Every Single Day
Until correction happens, survival becomes conditional.
Pensions stop. Subsidies fade. Medical support disappears. Families reduce food. Medicines are skipped. Savings dry up. Loans accumulate.
Certain corrections take months. Others take years. Some never arrive.
During this time, no institution monitors what the family suffers through. No report tracks hunger caused by delayed paperwork. No officer is asked how many lives were damaged during correction delays.
When the record is updated, the file closes.
But the damage stays.
Psychological Damage Without a File Number
Living as an officially “dead” person creates a constant sense of insecurity.
People stopped asserting their rights.
They hesitate to question authority.
They are afraid of attracting attention.
Even after correction, many people avoid government schemes completely. Not because they are ineligible, but because they can’t take another round of humiliation.
Trust breaks silently. Confidence collapses internally.
This is more than just an administrative error.
This is institutional trauma.
Why Accountability Never Arrives
Such cases rarely trigger investigations because responsibility is fragmented. Each department considers the problem as someone else’s fault.
Errors are defined as technical.
Suffering is considered personal.
No officer faces repercussions for wrongfully erasing. No compensation is provided for lost years. There are no reforms that follow.
The system corrects data, not damage.
And the cycle continues.
A Crime Without Handcuffs
No FIR is registered.
No courtroom hears testimony.
No headlines call it violence.
Yet this is systemic harm, quiet, persistent, and destructive.
When a system can erase someone’s existence, force them to beg for recognition, and avoid accountability, it is harmful by design.
What This Says About Governance
Digitisation was intended to increase efficiency and transparency. However, when systems function without responsibility, empathy, or human review, technology becomes authoritarian.
Data becomes the absolute truth.
Human presence becomes secondary.
In this equation, dignity has no place.
The Reality Few Acknowledge
By the time a record is corrected, something irreversible has occurred.
Confidence is damaged.
Trust is broken.
Self-respect is permanently shaken.
The system moves on.
The person never fully does.
The Question That Can No Longer Be Ignored
How many people are alive in India today who are invisible to the system meant to protect them?
How many people are quietly moving from office to office, bowing their heads, repeating the same excuse, and paying the consequence for an error they never made?
And how long will basic survival such as food, healthcare, identity, and dignity necessities like continue to require state permission to exist?
Sources & Reporting Basis
- NCRB data on suicides linked to economic and livelihood distress
- Indian media reports on wrongful death records and benefit exclusions.
- Government audit observations on welfare delivery failures
- Psychological research on institutional trauma and dignity loss
More Stories
The Slow Exit: How Employees Are Pushed Out Without Being Fired
Going Offline. Don’t Wait: Bengaluru’s Fourth Incident Raises New Questions
Going Offline. Don’t Wait: The Silicon Ghosts Hunt the City’s Tech Minds